Custom Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

Celebrate your special events and make memories with our custom cakes and pies made with homemade ice cream from Chicago Mike's in Highwood. Check out what we have to offer.

7" Cakes

Serves 6-8 people, Choice of 1 or 2 flavors. Crust available are Chocolate or Vanilla Cake. All cakes are topped with fresh whipped cream, choice of toppings: rainbow or chocolate sprinkles, peanuts, pecans, crushed Oreos, Chips Ahoy cookies or Biscoff cookies, or variety of candy. 1 mini cone with a mini scoop of ice cream on top included on each cake unless it is a picture cake. 3 days notice required.

7" $40

9" Cake

Serves 8-12 People. Choose 1 or 2 flavors of ice cream. Crust available are Chocolate or Vanilla Cake. All cakes are topped with fresh whipped cream, choice of toppings: rainbow or chocolate sprinkles, peanuts, pecans, crushed Oreos, Chips Ahoy cookies or Biscoff cookies or choice of a variety of candy. 2 mini cones with mini ice cream scoop included on top of each cake, unless it is a picture cake. 3 days notice required.

9" -$52

9" Pie

Choice of 1 ice cream flavor. Crust choices: Oreo or graham cracker crust. All pies are topped with fresh whip cream and decorated according to ice cream flavor or create your own. 1 days notice required.

Pie - $28

Cookie Dough Explosion

7" or 9"cake. Choose 1 or 2 flavors. We recommend Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and Milk Chocolate Ice Cream. Topped with chocolate ganache drip, chocolate chip cookies around the base of the cake, cookie dough scoops, more cookie dough and cookies in the center of the cake, whipped topping and a chocolate cake crust.

7"- $43 9"- $56, Pie $32

Chocolate Peanut Butter Overload

7 or 9 " cake, Loaded with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream, chocolate ganache topping and peanut butter drizzle, chocolate cake and fresh whipped cream.

7" - $43 9" - $56, Pie $32

Celebration Cake

7"or 9" cake, made with your choice of ice cream, chocolate ganache topping, cookies, mini ice cream cones, assorted candy bars, sprinkles, Oreo or sprinkle trim. Choice of cake.

7" - $43 9" $56

Photo Image Cake

Create custom cake with favorite image. Call to customize this cake. Prices vary

Oreo Supreme

7"or 9" cake, made with Cookie Jar Ice cream, chocolate ganache drip , Oreo cookies and chocolate cake.

7" - $40 9" - $52

Sugared Cherry & Oreo Cake

7"or 9" cake , made with your choice of Ice Cream, topped with fresh whipped cream and sugared cherries & Oreos. Choice of cake

7" -$40 9" - $52, Pie $28

Triple Decker Pie

Made with scoops of Vanilla Bean, Strawberry 'n Cream & Milk Chocolate over fudge and a layer of Cookie Jar or Milk Chocolate Ice Cream nestled in an Oreo crust

$32

Confetti Blast Cake

7 " or 9" cake, made with your choice of ice cream and cake base. Loaded with confetti sprinkles and fresh whipped cream. Please let us know if you want the smiley face.

7"-$43, 9"-$56

Santa Cake